I was home for Easter one year during university – I’m not sure which year it was but I’m banking on my third, when my living accommodations were a nightmare. As I looked out on the dismal pre-Spring brown of dead earth and mud I said to my dad, ‘I really don’t like Easter. Nothing good ever happens to me this time of year.’ Dad looked up from the grapefruit he was peeling and said, ‘I doubt our Lord was too fond of it, either.’
I laughed. My dad could always make me do that, no matter how dark the times.
Growing up it seemed the weather was always filthy over the Easter break. My first and later second big break ups played out over the Easter weekend. I came to loathe that time of year.
In 2011, Will and Kate decided to get married the week after Easter, which meant two four day weekends in a row for us living in England. I contacted Andrew, my travel partner, and said, ‘We’ve done northern France, now how about the South?’
He was in. After some plotting and planning we decided we’d fly into Carcassonne, rent a car, and head out on a Knight’s Templar tour.
‘I should warn you, though. Nothing good ever happens to me over Easter,’ I said. ‘Best be prepared.’
‘I will keep it in mind,’ he said.
I landed in Carcassonne a day before Andrew, armed with a new map and a plan. While most people would consider me well-travelled, Andrew makes me look like a homebody. So I decided to do some exploring before he landed, so I could show off a bit. After dumping my bags at my less than spectacular hotel located on the Canal du Midi, I made my way to the fortified city on the hill. It was a thirty-minute walk, give or take, but I can’t be sure, as I was distracted by the shoe shops. The modern city of Carcassonne is home to so many nice shoes stores that I started taking pictures of the window displays and sending them to my sister, who owns so many shoes her husband has dreams of them falling out of the kitchen cupboard and landing on him. The sun was shining and it was the start of a two week holiday in France. Frankly, it doesn’t get much better in my world.
Eventually I made it to the medieval city, perched majestically on a hill, only having to ask for directions twice – once when I was standing under a sign with a big arrow pointing to my destination. The lovely tall Dutch lad barely laughed as he turned me around by my shoulders and pointed. ‘Right!’ I said, and I was off. I clocked the different entrances and exits, aided by the fact that you needed to cross a drawbridge, so it wasn’t like I was looking for a small exit sign. Step one was done – I knew how to get to the old city.
Legend has it Carcassonne got its name from the dame of the castle, who, when it was under attack and she learned there was only one pig and one bag of wheat left, fed the pig and flung it to the attackers, who upon seeing the hefty flying side of bacon, assumed the people inside had enough supplies to keep them going for a spell and left. After the attack was thwarted the city bells rang for her, or the ‘carcas sona’. No one knows if the story is true or not but as I stood there I found myself hoping the pig was dead before it was launched over the incredibly high walls.
As I wandered, I studied my path with all the attention of Hansel and Gretel being led into the forest, clocking interesting things to point out to my friend and making note of shops I could use as reference points. After walking around for a few hours, I figured I’d learned enough that I could impress my friend. So I headed back to the land of shoe shops, thinking a treat was in order. I was feeling pretty good about myself.
The roads slope down from the medieval city, the houses interspersed with shops. As I looked, and walked, I saw a gentleman in a suit standing on the sidewalk. As I got closer he smiled at me, and I saw that his pinstripe suit was well made but old, not in tune with current trends. I could picture him, a much younger man, being measured by a tailor, perhaps for his wedding. That made me like him for some reason. As I approached, I saw that he was standing in front of a World War II Museum. He asked me if I would like to look around, and I nodded, smiling. How could I say no to a man who put on a suit to work at a museum? I stepped inside thinking I would give it twenty minutes and then hit the shoe shops. He was pleased as he ushered me through the door, and I got the feeling that whatever was inside was very important to this lovely man.
The museum was small, like it had been converted from a family home. I was greeted with that smell that seems unique to museums, like old manuscripts and dust, a scent that makes me feel nostalgic. I paid a small fee to enter, a few euros at best. The man told me a bit about the museum, but I was working so hard to understand his French, I missed the context of most of it. He gave me a brief tour of the layout and told me to find him if I had any questions. I could see the sunshine out the main door, and a part of me wondered how long I had to stay to make a good show. I wasn’t in museum mode, I was in walking in the sunshine and buying shoes mode. Plus, I wanted to find a good restaurant for my friend’s first night in town, and a bakery to buy breakfast. I had plans!
But the more I walked, the further the museum seemed to go. It was not wide but deep, and must have been two family homes originally, possibly three. I bypassed the clothing part, as military uniforms make me itchy looking at them. I read about Jean Moulin, the hero of the Resistance. And then I discovered some older photos, black and white, and gravitated towards them.
I love looking at pictures of young soldiers from World War II. I am not sure why, but it is unique to this period. When I see pictures of soldiers from World War I want to hold them in my arms. I send up prayers they weren’t gassed. World War I makes me weep in a way few things do, so I tend to be gentle with myself where photos are concerned. Soldiers from World War II all seem to me to be so handsome. They have a twinkle about them. I know the darkness, the evil, but I concentrate on the gallantry of the time.
I started flipping through the photos, placed like we used to stack albums at record stores. But they weren’t soldiers. I wasn’t quite sure of the theme at first, but then it dawned on me. Jews being rounded up. And suddenly the sunshine outside dimmed, and I got that weird, tight feeling in my throat that happens when you think of the Holocaust. My hands shook a little, and I looked to see the man in the suit watching me. I could have stopped, but that seemed wrong. Each person in the photo had a story, and in some small way I felt I was honouring them, perhaps remembering them, simply by looking. Isn’t that a responsibility we all have when it comes to history?
The photos were 8 by 10 with the white border you used to see, pressed against cardboard and covered with protective plastic. Women lined up at a concentrations camp. Naked. One of them holding a baby in her arms. I didn’t need to read the caption to know they were told they were going to the showers. But it was the gas chambers. We’ve seen those photos in history books. We know what happened.
I could not stop staring at the woman holding the baby. I thought about how afraid that mother must have been. I thought about what faced them. I thought about her pregnancy and if she had been excited or scared, knowing what was happening in her world. But there was more to it, something else. The way her hair was cut at the back, the way she was holding the baby. The slope of her shoulders. She looked exactly like my sister, in a picture I have of her holding her daughter, wearing blue shorts and a taupe shirt in the backyard of my parent’s home many years ago. We had a summer barbecue that day and it was a contest to see who could love my new niece the most.
My heart started to race, and the room tipped slightly. I remember pressing my left hand against the shelf to steady me. A little voice said, ‘It’s ok, put the picture down, step outside, it’s over.’ But I couldn’t. A few hours earlier I had been sending that same sister pictures of shoe shops. Now I was looking at her double, a few moments from death at the hands of the Nazis. Holding a baby. My eyes filled with tears and I knew I was in for one of those crying jags that you feel inside, days after your tears dry. Standing there, looking at the photo, I made space for a new kind of pain in my heart.
I don’t know how long I stood and stared. When I lifted my head the man in the suit was walking towards me, a concerned look on his face. I knew I was pale, for I had felt the colour drain from my body, as my heart felt like it was working overtime to keep me standing up. It felt like someone had picked me up and shaken me, and even as it was happening, I was staggered by how my body was responding to this photo.
I set the picture down gently, as though my physical actions might cause the woman to drop the baby. I thanked the man in the pinstripe suit that had held up well but had seen better days, and for a few seconds I saw a fedora on his head. It was so clear, I blinked a couple of times, and it disappeared. But I knew I had seen it. I still know it, now, all these years later.
I made my way outside. The sun was high in the sky, the day in full bloom. I put my sunglasses on because tears were still falling and dipped my head, which I think is universal code for I’m falling apart but pretend you don’t see me. I walked awkwardly back to the main part of the city, adrenalin making me so twitchy that when I checked my phone to see my sister’s messages, like that was proof she was alive and unharmed in Nova Scotia, it slipped from my hand and clattered across the street.
I have never felt so wobbly in my life, and that included when I worked in radio and suffered from vertigo. Instead of buying shoes, I sat at a café and drank a big glass of wine, then went back to my hotel, curled up like a hedgehog, and tried to get warm again.
The next day I met Andrew at the tiny airport. I had wanted to greet him as he got off the plane, but I was late getting there after a lousy night’s sleep. My plans to impress him were shaky at best, as I concentrated on plastering on a smile and being happy, dammit, all while thinking I might be sick at any moment. I took comfort in the fact that if I looked rough, he would think it was due to a few glasses of wine the night before. Being sad on vacation is just not done, although in 2009 we both cried our way across the Somme.
‘I walked to the medieval city yesterday, so I know the way. It’s really pretty, and I’m so glad the sun is shining today,’ I had a slightly manic note in my voice, and I knew he could hear it by the way he studied me. We picked up our rental car and headed out. As the car made its way up the hill to the old city we passed the museum. I turned away from it, beaming my attention on my friend. I didn’t want to see the man in the suit. I didn’t want to think about the picture. But that was the only thing I was thinking about.
And so we climbed, up the path, to the drawbridge, and entered.
‘I wonder what the knights would think if they came back and discovered they fought and died so that this place could sell t-shirts?’
‘But think of the good stuff they would experience!’ I said.
‘Like hot showers and better career options than being a knight?’
‘Exactly.’
That is why Andrew and I travel well together. We have a similar outlook on life and a love of travel which helps, but our sense of humour is in sync. And it felt good to laugh with a friend. It kept some of the darkness at bay. But with each step I took, I carried her with me, that woman who was photographed on her last day of life, that baby who never got to live. I pointed out a well, and the few things I remembered, but mostly we walked silently, the sunshine on our shoulders. Every time I feel that it makes me happy to be alive. But it also made me feel guilty, too. I’ve had it pretty easy, overall.
In the bright sunlight of the day we sat in a back garden in the medieval city and drank beer and ate croque monsieurs and planned our trip. As we left, I asked if we could walk a different path to the main city. Andrew lifted his head, looked around for a few seconds then pointed, and we headed left. After a few blocks I knew where we were. All the plans I made to impress him crumbled around me.
We walked around the quiet city, the shops closed since it was Good Friday. We ended up buying groceries and eating on a picnic bench outside the gite where we were staying. The woman who owned the place was recently divorced and had an air of hurt and loneliness about her that made me want to hold her hand. Andrew opened a bottle of wine we’d bought, and we drank it together, while I thought about the pain of loneliness. As I sat there on the second day of my vacation, I remembered telling my dad nothing good ever happened to me over Easter. If he were still alive then I would have called him, told him about the photo, said the Easter curse had struck again. But he was gone, and I was on my own.
Six months after the trip to France I found myself with my sister, walking along a Florida beach as the Atlantic Ocean shimmered besides us. I thought about telling her about that photo in Carcassonne but was hesitant. Would she want to know I saw her doppelganger in a photo at a death camp? I didn’t think so. And somehow it didn’t seem right to bring the darkness into the few moments of perfect light we were experiencing.
I have thought a lot about those two weeks in April long ago that changed me somehow. Thought about it until the starkness of it faded and it became its own part of memory. I think about it again now as we commemorate World Holocaust Day, seeing dignitaries lay wreaths at Auschwitz, hearing the incredible stories and unparalleled dignity of the few survivors who remain. I have thought about it as I believe more and more in reincarnation, and I wonder what fated me to see that photo.
Nothing good happens to me over Easter. But nothing truly terrible has ever happened either. I learned that in France, from a charming man in a blue suit, who I pictured in a fedora, and who I still wish I had hugged.