Most of what makes a book good is that
we are reading it at the right time for us.
…Alain de Botton
On a recent trip to Canada it was brought to my attention that I often make book recommendations to friends. As I shared a book I was reading and enjoying during a coffee outing, a friend said he kept a running list of my recommendations on his phone, while another told me how much she enjoyed a book I had recommended to her. The new participant in the conversation took out a pen and a notepad to write down the title of the book I was reading and liked, and I felt a tiny thrill at this. Later, when signing my own books at an event, I suggested another title to someone purchasing my book. The bookstore employee laughed and thanked me for supporting other authors. I shrugged. I like books. I like talking about books. It feels very natural to me, perhaps because books have always been a huge part of my life and have provided a blueprint for living that I very much needed. As I read about people going through desperate times I have found myself thinking if they can survive this… But that’s another blog I’m not quite ready to write.
Over the years my recommends list has changed, and sometimes I provide caveats, like with the Catcher in the Rye. I loved it when I was younger (see opening quote) but my all-consuming love for Holden Caulfied has waned over the years as life took away some of my own softness, I think. There are other books that I think have a distinct audience. I recommended The Girl’s Guide to Hunting and Fishing to a lot of female friends who claimed not to like to read, knowing it would sway them, and it did. I don’t think I ever recommended it to a male friend.
I have some books that live inside me that I don’t so much recommend as almost force people to read. Books that spoke to me, changed me, made me think, and books I return to for comfort. Some where the writing skill left me in awe, some that helped me become a better person. A few of which I consider friends. I’ve written about some of them here.
The Bell Jar by Sylvia Plath.
It was a queer, sultry summer, the summer they electrocuted the Rosenbergs, and I didn’t know what I was doing in New York.
How is that for an opening line? As far as I’m concerned, it doesn’t get any better. The reader meets Esther Greenwood, a young woman from a poor background suddenly working at a fashion magazine in New York. Her story of trying to find her way spoke volumes to me, and not long after I moved to England I drove to Hebden Bridge in Yorkshire where she is buried to pay my respects to a woman who left this world far too young, and who had similar taste in men as myself. I own several copies of the Bell Jar and have bought it endlessly as gifts. The writing is sublime from beginning to end, with the last line of the book as powerful as the first: I took a deep breath and listened to the old brag of my heart: I am, I am, I am.
The Vanishing Act of Esme Lennox by Maggie O’Farrell
I don’t know how this book came into my possession. I think an old boss of mine said she liked the author, Maggie O’Farrell. My copy is slightly banged up and looks like it may have been exposed to the rain. Usually this bothers me, but I think the wear and tear adds to the impact of the off-white jacket with red lettering.
The premise for the story is simple – while at work one day Iris Lockhart gets a call that changes everything she knows about her family. She learns she has a great aunt who has been locked away in an asylum for years and Iris needs to find her a new place to live. She brings her to live with her in Edinburgh and soon family secrets come to the surface. It is a look at how society treated women who dared not to conform, and how perceived shame and the lies told to cover it up twists lives for generations. A thousand thumbs up.
Six Graves To Munich by Mario Puzo
Once upon a time as a publishing sales rep, I had the supreme good fortune of selling books chosen by the legend that is Christopher MacLehose. Six Grave In Munich was written by Mario Puzo (of The Godfather fame) under the name Mario Cleri. It tells the story of an intelligence officer named Michael Rogan captured by the Gestapo who survives being tortured and returns to Germany ten years later to seek revenge. I don’t want to ruin the story for anyone but let me tell you in this story, recollections indeed vary. Cleri has a handful of characters involved in the same event who have entirely different memories and interpretations of what happens – a strong reminder that you never know what someone else is thinking.
I remember setting the book down and wondering what kind of wizard Puzo was, that he could have one straightforward act of evil be so nuanced and misunderstood in its retelling. I’m still in awe of his understanding of human nature and his writing skill.
I know This Much Is True Wally Lamb
This is an enormous doorstop of a book, and I’ve read it twice. Another perfect opening line: On the afternoon of October 12, 1990, my twin brother Thomas entered the Three Rivers, Connecticut Public Library, retreated to one of the rear study carrels, and prayed to God the sacrifice he was about to commit would be deemed acceptable.
As we say in the Martimes, Gentle God. This book ripped my heart out and even as I clutched the tissues, I could not stop reading it.
I Know This Much Is True tells the story of twins Thomas and Dominick Birdsey, one who has schizophrenia and one who does not. They are being raised by their mother and stepfather, a man with questionable parenting skills. As a reader you feel for both brothers for different reasons, and you wonder just how much a person can deal with and survive. It is a story about family loyalty and (for me perhaps) a look at how seemingly small events leave deep, lasting scars.
The world would be a better place if we all had a brother like Dominick Birdsey.
Anna Karenina
One of a handful of books I have read more than once. On the surface it is a story of a married woman who leaves her husband when she falls for a younger man. Not exactly groundbreaking now, but at the time this was a slap in the face to all societal norms. Each time I read it, I see something new. As a sixteen-year-old reading it in high school, I felt deeply for Anna and wondered why she couldn’t trust her love with and for Count Vronsky. In university I started to think about the destructiveness of passion and guilt in life. The last time I read it I thought about how destructive relationships can be, and how Anna’s life would have been easier had she stayed home the night she met Vronsky, but that comes from my own life experience now.
Recently I found myself wondering if Tolstoy’s editor asked him to change the ending, to make it more palatable and filmable perhaps. Again, life’s experiences coming into the mix.
Travels with My Aunt by Graham Greene
I like Graham Greene. I liked Our Man In Havana although I didn’t really understand it the first time I read it. I think Dr Fisher of Geneva, a story about a man who invites people to a dinner party who can either win a million dollars or be struck down by a b*mb was clever, a literary precursor to Survivor.
Travels With My Aunt is a story of a retired bank manager who meets a woman he believes is his aunt at a funeral and embarks on a European adventure with her. I read it sitting in the library of my high school and found in inspiring. Greene’s other books seem to have more acclaim, but this was his best for me. Perhaps because I didn’t have to ask anyone about Cuba and the Missile Crisis to understand the different paths we take, or how we can be done in by our own fears and settle for too quiet of a life. It shows us how the people we meet change our lives – for better or worse. It is yet another story dealing with family secrets but to me it was the main character’s move from tending his dahlias to embarking on smuggling as a career choice that spoke to me as I sat in my high school library, biding my time.
Lean On Pete by Willy Vlautin
Willy Vlautin is a modern-day Steinbeck, telling stories of the poor and marginalised with a touch that keeps it genuine and eye opening without being too heavy. Victor Hugo could have learned a few things from Mr Vlautin (and yes, I know he died long before Vlautin was born). I read Les Miserables when I was too young and found myself worrying about Fantine when I should have been paying attention in math class.
Charley Thompson is a young man left orphaned after the death of his father. He befriends an old racehorse named Lean On Pete and decides to save him when he is going to be put out to pasture for good. Charley also wants to find an estranged aunt of his as he does not want to end up in care. It is a coming of age story that reminds you how hard some people have it, and how much we all struggle.
Rilla of Ingleside
A young read perhaps, but I have yet to outgrow it.
Rilla is the daughter of Anne Shirley, better known as Anne of Green Gables. Anne married Gilbert Blythe and had seven children (only six of which survive into adulthood)
before moving to Glen St Mary and living in a big house called Ingleside. Rilla was born Bertha Marilla (And why would you do that to a kid?) which was shortened to Rilla; she came of age as World War one raged.
The book opens at a lighthouse party where news of war in Europe breaks out, exciting the young men and boring the young women. We then spend four years with Rilla as she navigates growing up while watching three of her brothers and so many of her chums go off to fight. It staggers me to this day how much I learned about World War One reading this book, and when I saw Courcelette, where tanks were first used in battle, it was of an imaginary character named Walter Blythe, son of Anne, who I thought. As I stood at Langemark German Cemetery in Belgium I thought about being twelve years old and reading about the Days of Langemarck (spelled with a ‘c’ back then).
The book introduced me to battles of the war, the world leaders at the time, and how Canada changed as a result of the conflict. As I read about the horrors and the heartache and grief of so many, it taught my twelve-year-old self empathy too, although I wish that was a lesson I learned after high school. Maybe after university, too.
Apart from Bill Bryson’s travel books, I don’t tend to read humour, but if that is your thing, I recommend The Stupidest Angel by Christopher Moore or anything by Carl Hiaasen. Because as we hear in Rilla of Ingleside, ‘A good laugh is as good as a prayer sometimes’.
Others for another post:
Lucy By the Sea Elizabeth Strout
The Magician’s Assistant Ann Patchett
The Art of Mending by Elizabeth Berg
Thin Places Kerri ni Dochartaigh


